It's Here

It's Here
Channel 4 helps protect your ID

°

Homepage / Jacksonville News
Text Size

5 Killed, 9 Hurt As Boat Hits Tug

Authorities Say Most Victims In 20s

POSTED: Monday, April 13, 2009
UPDATED: 11:46 pm EDT April 13, 2009

One day after 22-foot Crownline boat crashed into a 25-foot tugboat in the Intracoastal Waterway, investigators said they've removed the boat from the area and will process it as a crime scene.

Five people died and at nine others were seriously hurt when the pleasure boat packed with 14 people slammed into the tugboat tied up to a dock under construction on Easter Sunday evening.

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission said a boat struck the tug docked along South Roscoe Road -- about one mile north of the Palm Valley Bridge.

"It had to be doing at least 30 to make that kind of noise and to go through the boat like that," said George Hume, who called 911 after hearing the crash and people screaming. "That boat went three or four feet into the other boat, so you know that that impact -- when it hit, those people just went forward. And, of course, those people were hitting steel."

St. Johns County fire-rescue personnel said the power boat penetrated the hull of the tug, as well as the wheelhouse and the engine compartment.

Rescuers used plywood pulled from the construction site to build a bridge to reach those in the water and wreckage.

"They took them to the barge and did a triage there to determine which patients were going to make it off the barge and across the improvised dock ... to be able to get them up to a treatment area," Chief Carl Shank of St. Johns County Fire-Rescue said.

ICW ax - boat out of water
The FWC has released the names of the 14 people who were on the boat when it hit a tugboat Sunday night.
  Story: FWC Names Victims In Boating Tragedy

KILLED:
  • Jacqueline R. Allen, 44, Jacksonville
  • Olivia Rose Carretero, 23, Lake Tahoe, Calif.
  • Robert Trenton Craig, 23, Jax Beach
  • Inmaculada Pierce, 42, Orange Park
  • Elisabeth Rosenfeld, 20, Ponte Vedra Beach
  •  INJURED:
  • Jacqueline Collins, 23, Ponte Vedra Beach
  • Brittney Joyce, 19, Jacksonville Beach
  • Amanda Barton, 22, Santa Rosa, Calif.
  • Melvin D. Bethel, 37, Ponte Vedra Beach
  • Karey Rae Cavicchioli, 19, Jax Beach
  • Jaimie A. Hole, 22, Santa Rosa, Calif.
  • Frank Moore, age unknown, California
  • Josh Moore, 18, California
  • Justin Thomas Moore, 23, Ponte Vedra
  • Five people were pronounced dead at the scene and at least seven others were transported to Jacksonville hospitals.

    By midday Monday, two of those at Shands-Jacksonville Medical Center remained in critical condition, one in serious condition and three in fair condition.

    One of those hospitalized was the boat's owner, Melvin Bethel, according to FWC Lt. Steve Zukowsky.

    "The boat has been removed from the water and is being processed now as a possible crime scene," Zukowsky said. "We're looking at things to see if there was possibly foul play. We have to rule that in or rule that out."

    The FWC, which was leading the investigation, had questioned several witnesses and was seeking others. The Coast Guard and National Transportation Safety Board have also joined the investigation to try to find out exactly what happened in the moments before the crash.

    Among the questions investigators were asking were why 14 people were on a 22-foot boat, how fast were they going, were the passengers wearing life vests and whether alcohol was involved.

    Authorities said it would take weeks to complete the investigation.

    Alan Oshier, of Neptune Beach, told Channel 4 that he had overslept or he would have been on board the boat, which left St. Augustine Beach's Conch House after the group had spent the afternoon of listening to music. The FWC believes the boat was headed back to Beach Marine at Jacksonville Beach when it hit the tug.

    St. Johns County Fire-Rescue spokesman Jeremy Robshaw described the rescue scene as chaotic, with firefighters, deputies and other agencies all trying to rescue victims.

    "You see tragedies occur from time to time, but this is a pretty significant thing," Robshaw told Channel 4.

    Text Size
    Text Size
    The views expressed are not those of News4Jax.com, WJXT or its affiliated companies. This is a community moderated forum. (Please note the 'Like' and 'Report' tabs.) By posting your comments you agree to accept our Terms of Use.

    Comments

    blog comments powered by Disqus

    Sponsored Links

    Links We Like

    Sponsored Content
    Check out our picks for the most luxurious and unique homes that were on the market in 2009. More

    Find out what a sputtering economy and an increasingly difficult to crack job market means to you. More

    The following tips can help your car become a less inviting target and slow down, discourage or actually prevent car theft. More

    Believing urban legends about sex could be hurting your sex life. Get the truth behind common sex myths. More

    Most Popular

    • StoriesClick to Expand

    • VideoClick to Expand

      • Donna Brock Calls From Jail

        Jail CallsExactly one year ago, Misty Cummings last saw 5-year-old Haleigh Cummings in their Satsuma home. The newest development in the investigation are a review of jailhouse interviews with five people connected to Haleigh now in jail on drug charges, including Donna Brock, a former employee with Equusearch.

      • How To Tell If Your Spouse Is Cheating (Part 2)

        Wedding ringsA local private investigator talks about some of the warning signs that your spouse is cheating. (Part 2)

      • Dentist Accused Of Dealing Crack

        Dentist Arrested An Arlington Dentist is ARRESTED -- accused of doing some dirty dealing, when he's not filling cavities. Police say he's been trading prescriptions for CRACK COCAINE. Channel 4's Jason law spoke with some neighbors and PATIENTS of the accused dentist tonight.

      • Do's, Don't For Shredder Day

        Shredder Day photoFrom 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Wednesday, Southland Recycling will be at Channel 4 accepting personal papers for shredding.

      • Jailhouse Surveillance Video: Hank Croslin Sr. Talks To Misty

        Hank Croslin Jr., the brother of Misty Cummings, talks to his wife from jail via video conferencing.

    • SlideshowsClick to Expand