Watch Live

Watch Live
Weekend newscasts online

°

Homepage / Jacksonville News
Text Size

First-Time Video Key To Murder Case

Amanda Butler Accused Of Killing Daughter In 2002

POSTED: Tuesday, June 23, 2009
UPDATED: 6:55 pm EDT June 23, 2009

Some key evidence was presented for the first time in the trial of a mother charged with murder.

Amanda Butler was accused of inducing the seizure that killed her 2-year-old daughter in 2002.

Butler has served time in West Virginia for committing a similar crime against her son.

Prosecutors said the video will become a key piece of their case.

The video is grainy and in many ways hard to decipher, but investigators said it's a key piece of evidence in the case against Butler.

Detectives said the video shows Butler with another child, Ryley, secretly recorded in a West Virginia hospital about 20 months after Cheyenne's death. Doctors there were suspicious because Butler's newborn son was showing some of the same symptoms as Cheyenne.

In the video, Butler is seen holding her son Ryley, and police said at several points she covers the child's mouth, once with her hand and then a few minutes later using a cloth. And in each instance, they said, she is keeping watch on the hospital room door.

Butler has said she was using the cloth in her hand to wipe crust off the boy's mouth. But police and prosecutors said it was something more diabolical.

Butler pleaded no contest to child abuse and served a year in jail in West Virginia.

Cheyenne Butler
Cheyenne Butler
The police report said during that time, she told one inmate "she was doing the same thing to Cheyenne as she did to Ryley."

A second inmate said Butler told her "on one occasion, it went a bit too far with Cheyenne."

And Butler told her she smothered Cheyenne to get her husband back home because she missed him.

Butler also said, "It was an accident. It didn't mean to happen."

Finally, Butler told the inmate that her children have Munchausen's, a syndrome in which the affected person exaggerates or creates symptoms of illness to gain attention and sympathy.

Immediately after her release in West Virginia in April 2006, Butler was arrested by JSO detectives to face murder charges.

Detectives said among the people they interviewed were Butler's neighbors and friends, some of who left their children in Butler's care.

One of them told detectives something else that could sway a jury.

In another supplemental report, he said that while Butler was baby-sitting their son, he had a seizure.

He found his son lying in a crib "stiff as a board and looking terrified."

And, he said, the child had no problems, until they once again allowed Butler to baby-sit.

Then there's the video. A lower court judge agreed with the defense and threw it out, saying it violated her privacy rights.

But an appeals court disagreed, and now the tape and documents will be part of the state's case against her.

Text Size
The views expressed are not those of News4Jax.com, WJXT or its affiliated companies. This is a community moderated forum. (Please note the 'Like' and 'Report' tabs.) By posting your comments you agree to accept our Terms of Use.

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

Sponsored Links

Links We Like

Sponsored Content
Before you splurge on that pricey remodeling project, beware. It may not pay you back when it's time to sell. More

Employers generally have options when it comes to hiring. Makes sure you present yourself as professionally as possible, or else. More

Want to lose weight? Get a diet and fitness plan customized for you from Jillian Michaels of TV’s Biggest Loser. MoreClick Here

The signs of Cancer can sometimes be very subtle. Here's a guide to help you recognize them early. More

Most Popular

  • StoriesClick to Expand

    • 11-Year-Old Girl Helps Deliver Baby

      Gainesville baby with mom and sisterAn 11-year-old Gainesville girl called 911 and helped her mom deliver her newborn baby sister when the big moment came before they could get to the hospital.

    • St. Augustine Woman Hit By Car Dies

      Florida Highway Patrol investigators said a pedestrian was killed Friday evening after being hit by several cars along a St. Johns County roadway.

    • Service Set For Children Killed By Dad

      Katie and Kevin WhitelawA family still coming to grips with the death of two children at the hands of their father -- who then took his own life -- announced plans for a Sunday memorial service.

    • Ida Spurs Storm Warnings In Caribbean

      T.S. Ida - Saturday 4 p.m.Tropical-storm warnings are issued for the Mexican coastline and a tentative forecast track predicted Tropical Storm Ida da could brush the U.S. Gulf Coast next week.

    • Senior Scores Perfect 2400 On SAT

      David AnthonyA Camden County High School senior scored a perfect 2400 on his SAT, amazing his teachers, parents and even himself.

  • VideoClick to Expand

  • SlideshowsClick to Expand

    • Your Photos Of Sea & Air Spectacular

      Air show pix: Blue Angels jet with flagSEE IT, SNAP IT, SEND IT: Thousands of eyes and nearly as many cameras are pointed toward the sky over Jacksonville's beaches this weekend for the Sea & Air Spectacular.

    • Images: Flames Engulf, Destroy Mobile Home

      Nassau County House FireAn 800 square foot mobile home in Nassau County was destroyed by fire Tuesday night. Both residents in the home escaped safely.

    • Quinn Gray Evidence Photos

      Quinn Gray shows injuries she says were a result of her kidnappingQuinn Gray showed investigators marks on her arms and legs she said were the result of her kidnapping. Slideshow

    • Have You Seen These Fugitives?

      WOJ-ANDRE-FULTZCapturing N.E. Florida's wanted suspects is a tough task, so the local station is trying to help with the Wheel of Justice. Every Thursday morning, the wheel spins and a wanted fugitive is profiled. Images: Fugitives On 'Wheel'

    • Blue Angels Thrill Crowd At NAS Jacksonville Air Show

      Air show imageAn extimated 200,000 people came to NAS Jacksonville Sunday to see the annual air show. Images From Air Show