JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -- A jury has recommended the death penalty for Rasheem Dubose, the third of three brothers convicted of killing an 8-year-old girl in 2006.
After two days of testimony in the sentencing phase and an afternoon of arguments by lawyers on both sides, the jury took just more than an hour to reach an 8-4 verdict.
With his two younger brothers already sentenced to life in prison for the crime, attorneys for Dubose, 25, tried to convince the jury the eldest brother should not receive the death penalty for the shooting death of Dreshawna Davis.
After the recommendation of death was read Thursday evening, Rasheem Dubose kicked over his chair and was led from the courtroom. The Dubose family left the courtroom in tears.
Both Dreshawna's grandmothers held hands with those around her as the recommendation was read.
"I'm just very grateful; I'm well satisfied with the verdict," said Vonnie Frasier, who was in the house with her granddaughter when the shots were fired. "I feel that death is truly deserved."
"It was a long case, and I truly miss Dreshawna," said Carlas Washington, the victim's paternal grandmother. "I think about her everyday. She's in my heart."
All three brothers were convicted earlier this year of first-degree murder and firing into an occupied dwelling in the killing of Dreshawna, who was killed when 29 shot were fired into her grandmother's home in July 2006.
Prosecutors called the shooting a retaliatory strike targeting Dreshawna's uncle, who had robbed and humiliated Rasheem Dubose earlier that day.
Last Friday, a jury recommended life sentences for Tajuan and Terrell Dubose. Judge Page Haddock immediately sentenced Tajuan, 21, to life in prison without possibility of parole, then did the same on Monday for Terrell, 23.
The recommendation of death for Rasheem Dubose will be taken under advisement by Judge Page Haddock. The actual sentencing is scheduled for April 23.
On the first day of the sentencing hearing, the Dubose brothers' grandmother was removed from the courtroom after prosecutors complained she had been speaking with other witnesses, which is forbidden.
After prosecutors reminded jurors of the facts of the case -- including the fact that the fatal shot was fired by Rasheem's gun -- and listed reasons Rasheem Dubose qualifies for the death penalty under Florida law. Then the defense team then called series of witnesses they said would to explain, not excuse, his actions.
Previous Stories: - March 9, 2010: Final Dubose Brother To Be Sentenced
- March 8, 2010: 2nd Dubose Brother Sentenced To Life
- March 5, 2010: Jury Recommends Life For Dubose Bros.
- March 2, 2010: Brothers May Face Death In Girl's Killing
- February 19, 2010: Verdict: 2 Dubose Brothers Also Guilty
- February 18, 2010: Rasheem Dubose Found Guilty Of Murder
- February 17, 2010: Closing Arguments End In Dubose Retrial
- February 16, 2010: State Rests Case In Dubose Retrial
- February 12, 2010: Witnesses Heard Shots Fired Into Home
- February 10, 2010: State Lays Out Case In Murder Retrial
- February 9, 2010: Jury Seated In Rasheem Dubose Retrial
- February 8, 2010: Retrial Of Rasheem Dubose Begins
- January 25, 2010: What's Next After Mistrial?
- January 23, 2010: Mistrial Leaves Families Waiting For Justice
- January 22, 2010: 1 Verdict Reached, 2nd Jury Deliberates
- January 21, 2010: 1 Jury Deliberates; 2nd Hears Arguments
- January 20, 2010: State: 3 Brothers, 1 Intent ... Murder
- January 19, 2010: Dreshawna's Uncle Testifies In Trial
- January 15, 2010: Cousin: Dubose Bros. Fired Into House
- January 14, 2010: Grandma: Bullets Ripped Through House
- January 13, 2010: State Lays Out Case Against 3 Brothers
- January 12, 2010: 1st Jury Picked In Brothers' Murder Trial
- October 29, 2009: 3 Brothers Await Trial In Girl's Death
- August 20, 2006: Police: Slain Girl's Great-Grandmother Threatened
- August 1, 2006: Defiant 'Persons Of Interest' Held Without Bond
- July 31, 2006: Sheriff: 3 Persons Of Interest In Girl's Slaying Caught In Home Burglary
- July 29, 2006: Uncle Questioned About 8-Year-Old's Slaying
- July 28, 2006: 'Another Senseless Murder' Takes Life Of 8-Year-Old
- July 27, 2006: Girl Killed In Drive-By Shooting
Copyright 2010 by News4Jax.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.