Judge Refuses To Dismiss Suit Against DCF In Foster-Home Death
The refusal to investigate and monitor the home showed the employees were "deliberately indifferent" to the welfare of Latiana Hamilton (pictured, left) and her older brother, Schlesinger said."All would agree that a person who pushes another person into a snake pit, lion den or pool of quicksand is a ... substantial cause of any resulting injuries or death directly inflicted by the snakes, lions or quicksand," Schlesinger said in an order Friday.Latiana was beaten and drowned in a bathtub by her foster mother, Lena Cumberbatch, and her brother was abused in the home in 2001.
Cumberbatch received a mandatory life prison sentence after being convicted of first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse.Attorney Dixon Bridgers, who represents the employees, said an appeal is likely to the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta, though no decisions have been made.Because the case is still being litigated, DCF spokesman John Harrell would not comment on the development."We are reviewing the decision and are exploring our legal options," Harrell told Channel 4.A similar lawsuit brought by the couple who adopted the boy after his sister died was dismissed in May by the 11th Circuit. That suit, the court ruled, did not show the DCF workers knew of the risk Cumberbatch presented to the children and were deliberately indifferent to it.The appeals panel ruled that government officials are immune from lawsuits if they did not knowingly violate anyone's rights, a legal concept known as "qualified immunity,"The U.S. Supreme Court has said the defense shields officials from the constant threat of being sued, and keeps officials from having to spend money and time on court proceedings.The suit was amended and motions were again heard in federal court. Schlesinger ruled that the amended lawsuit can continue, saying the department ignored evidence of abuse and Cumberbatch's own statements about being unable to handle all the children DCF was sending her.Attorneys settled cases filed against DCF on Latiana's behalf, but the cases involving her brother, now 7, weren't part of the settlement.Copyright 2006 by News4Jax.com. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.






A hurricane watch went up Sunday from southeastern Louisiana to the Florida Panhandle as Hurricane Ida becomes a Category 2 hurricane.
An 11-year-old Gainesville girl called 911 and helped her mom deliver her newborn baby sister when the big moment came before they could get to the hospital.
The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office has identified the man police shot after he allegedly robbed a Family Dollar store on the Northside.
Crime scene investigators took video of inside Quinn Gray's home the night she was reported missing. Detectives were looking for evidence. Gray claimed she was forced from her home at gunpoint and cops considered it a crime scene.
Five men visiting Gainesville for a massive underground punk party were arrested after police said they beat an officer and it was all caught on tape.
Sept. 9, 2008: Ponte Vedra Beach mother Quinn Gray describes her very physical relationship with the man she said abducted her.
Police said Osmanovic and Gray spent several nights at a south metro motel, and on one particular morning, Osmanovic wore a recording device and said he was going back to the hotel room to be with Gray.
The St. Johns County Sheriff's Office arrested 34 people Friday morning in connection with illegal narcotics transactions.
SEE IT, SNAP IT, SEND IT: Thousands of eyes and nearly as many cameras pointed toward the sky over Jacksonville's beaches this weekend for the Sea & Air Spectacular.
Quinn Gray showed investigators marks on her arms and legs she said were the result of her kidnapping.
Slideshow
Capturing N.E. Florida's wanted suspects is a tough task, so the local station is trying to help with the Wheel of Justice. Every Thursday morning, the wheel spins and a wanted fugitive is profiled.
Images: Fugitives On 'Wheel'
An 800 square foot mobile home in Nassau County was destroyed by fire Tuesday night. Both residents in the home escaped safely.
An extimated 200,000 people came to NAS Jacksonville Sunday to see the annual air show.
Images From Air Show