Sam Kouvaris: Time for Jimmy in The Pride

Will Keenan McCardell be next inducted into Jags' Pride ring?

Jaguars WR Jimmy Smith, left, signs autographs for fans on July 30, 2005. (AP File Photo/Phil Coale)

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – There’s never been a question about Jimmy Smith’s on-field greatness. Smith is one of just three players to play more than 10 seasons for the Jaguars, from 1995-2005, and still owns 11 team records 10 years after his retirement in 2006.

But how do you honor a player during his much-publicized struggle with drug addition and run-ins with the law?

Recommended Videos



Jimmy’s battles with drug abuse were well chronicled on ESPN’s “30 for 30” series, among other places.

He’s served jail time and has been confined to his house and convicted on drug and parole violation charges. He’s still on parole in Mississippi until March of next year.

Even his retirement in 2006 was surrounded by controversy. In a hastily called press conference, Smith said he was “tired” and it “was time” for him to retire. He denied that he might have been facing a year’s suspension for failing another drug test at the time.

But walking away from several million dollars didn’t make any sense for Smith at that point in his career. Even how the announcement was handled for one of the all-time, on-field greats didn’t seem right.

Smith's denial was unconvincing and tepid at best.

As fans and friends have hoped, Smith has stayed out of trouble for a few years, long enough for the Jaguars to honor him this December as a member of The Pride.

“There is no question that Jimmy Smith was one of the best players to ever wear a Jaguars uniform,” Jaguars owner Shad Khan said. “His contributions in the early years were critical to the success the Jaguars enjoyed during that time. The fact that most of his records have stood for 10 years without being surpassed underscores what a great player he was.”

Serving on the Pro Football Hall of Fame Selection Committee, I’m instructed every year to only consider a player’s football accomplishments, disregarding any issues he might have outside the game. That’s why Lawrence Taylor was elected to the hall during a time he was consistently running afoul of the law.

But The Pride of the Jaguars is different -- if only by the definition of the word “Pride.”

In this case, it has double meaning, denoting a collection of individuals and a spirit of those involved. It would have been tough to induct Smith during his troubled times.

A five-time Pro Bowl performer, Smith was a key to the Jaguars’ early success when the team earned four straight playoff appearances from 1996-99 and played in eight postseason games, including two AFC Championship games. He was the Jaguars’ leading receiver seven times and was voted to the AFC Pro Bowl team five consecutive years from 1997-2001.

“We had such great fun and I have wonderful memories of my time there,” Smith said. "I want to experience it once again with my teammates and the great Jaguars fans. This is a great honor.”

Smith joined the Jaguars as a free agent in 1995, and over the next 11 seasons he produced marks for receptions, receiving yards and receiving touchdowns that still stand today. His 171 games played and 150 games started both rank second in team history, and his 11 seasons played is tied for second all-time.

Part of Jimmy’s success was the team around him.  Fellow Pride members Mark Brunell, Tony Boselli and Fred Taylor helped anchor a very potent offense during Smith’s career. 

Which also raises the question: “What about Keenan?” No matter where McCardell ranks statistically in Jaguars receiving history, he was a force opposite Smith that put pressure on defenses and gave Smith room to roam.  They were even promoted together as “Thunder and Lightning” during their playing days.

Maybe they’re spacing it out, but if Jimmy’s going in, Keenan should be there with him.

Or at least next.

Then Meester.