Oh Say Can You Sing is proud to have Papa John's as its sponsor, so we decided to ask our finalists to tell us what toppings they would enjoy on their perfect Papa John's pizza.
Godiva says her favorite pizza would be topped with mushrooms, black olives and pineapple. Lauren went much simpler with mushrooms and extra cheese. Zoe's choice was a little more carnivorous with bacon, sausage and olives. And Vince went with sausage and pineapple.
We took your pulse and found that the vast majority, or 54 percent of voters, thought Godiva's toppings were the best combination.