4th Green Cove Springs murder suspect denied bond

Ozell McNabb Jr. first appearance in Clay County court
Ozell McNabb Jr. first appearance in Clay County court

GREEN COVE SPRING, Fla. – A 22-year-old murder suspect wanted in connection with a double shooting that took the life of an 18-year-old man surrendered Tuesday to the St. Johns County Sheriff's Office, deputies said.

Ozell McNabb Jr. appeared in court Wednesday morning after he was transferred Tuesday afternoon to the Clay County Jail, where he is being held on charges of felony murder and armed robbery. He was denied bond.

McNabb is one of four people suspected in the shooting death of 18-year-old Kolton Shearer. On Sunday, deputies arrested Jordan Tyler Coleman, 20, Taurean Johnson, 28, and Alexandra Schreffler, 21, in the robbery and shooting.

McNabb called the St. Johns County Sheriff's Office on Tuesday afternoon and told deputies where he was and that he was tired of running, deputies said. He was dropped off along State Road 13 in the Orangedale area and waited for deputies to come pick him up.

McNabb told investigators he wanted to cooperate, but he requested an attorney, so detectives could not question him yet. 

The Clay County Sheriff's Office had asked the U.S. Marshals Service to help find McNabb, a fourth suspect in the shooting at a Green Cove Springs home early Sunday.

Clay County detectives said they believe McNabb left the county at some point Monday, but they're not sure how he left or where he was hiding before he turned himself in Tuesday.

Detectives said McNabb, along with Coleman, Johnson and Schreffler, were with Shearer and two other people at the home on County Road 16A near Idlewild Avenue around 2 a.m. The reason for the meeting was not known, but investigators said they believe robbery was the motive for the incident. They said someone in the group of four started shooting, killing Shearer and hitting a second victim, David Levo, in the leg.

After Shearer was shot, another person drove him in a pickup truck to a Kangaroo gas station about 1 mile away for help. The driver, whose name was not released, was not injured and tried to save Shearer by giving him CPR in the gas station parking lot, deputies said. 

Shearer died of his injures before rescue arrived. Levo had surgery Monday and is expected to recover. He remained hospitalized Tuesday.

Shearer, who graduated from Middleburg High School two months ago, was a member of the Broncos' baseball team and had earned a scholarship at South Georgia State College.

Friends of Shearer have organized a vigil for him at 8 p.m. Wednesday at Ronnie Van Zant Park at 2760 Sandridge Road in Lake Asbury.

Johnson, Schreffler and Coleman, who are each charged with felony murder and robbery, made their first court appearances Monday morning and were each denied bond. They will be arraigned Aug. 12.

Coleman and Schreffler, who are a couple, live in the house where the shooting occurred, deputies said.

Schreffler, who was visibly upset and wiped away tears during as she spoke to judges Monday morning, is on suicide watch, deputies said. She has no criminal history in Clay County.

Johnson has an extensive arrest history and was recently released from prison. His prior arrests include charges of cocaine possession, sale of an altered firearm and home invasion.

The home invasion convicted landed Johnson in prison for seven years. He was released in April.

McNabb has prior arrests for conspiracy to commit armed robbery, for which he served six months in jail, and twice for possession of marijuana.

Coleman has prior arrests for burglary, criminal mischief and three times for petit theft.

Coleman's father, who asked to be identified only as Robert, said he does not believe his son pulled the trigger. He said he was sick and disgusted over Shearer's killing.

Robert said Coleman has had problems, but he has never been violent and that he "made a huge mistake, but did not pull the trigger."

Clay County detectives said they believe they have identified everyone involved in the robbery and shooting and will review the case with the State Attorney's Office this week.