Jury seated in St. Augustine double murder trial

James Colley charged with murdering wife & friend in 2015 rampage

By Ethan Calloway - Anchor/reporter, Ashley Harding - Reporter

ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. - Nearly three years after authorities said James Colley Jr. shot his estranged wife and her friend in a rampage at the couple's St. Johns County home, a jury has been seated in the 38-year-old's double murder trial.

Of 60 prospective jurors brought in Monday, all but 11 were dismissed. At the judge's request, 30 more were added to the pool Tuesday and jury selection continued into Wednesday afternoon before a full jury was seated.

Opening statements will begin Thursday morning.

Colley is charged with two counts of first-degree murder, two counts of attempted first-degree murder, two burglary counts and a count of aggravated stalking in the August 2015 shooting of Amanda Colley, 36, and Lindy Dobbins, 39.

Before Amanda Colley was killed, she had taken out a restraining order against James Colley, but authorities said Colley ignored the order and burned his wife's clothes in the yard, among other violations.

At a court hearing Aug. 27, 2015, a judge told Colley to stay away from his wife and handed down a 60-day suspended sentence on the restraining order violation charge.

James ColleyBut immediately following the hearing, Colley went to his father’s home to get a gun and then drove to the couple’s home, opening fire on Amanda Colley and her friends, according to prosecutors.

Dobbins was fatally shot as she and another friend, Rachel Hendricks, hid in a closet. Amanda Colley was slain as she took cover inside a bathroom.

Authorities said Colley was looking for Lamar Douberly, who he suspected of having a relationship with his wife, when he walked up through the backyard and opened fire into the residence.

Douberly and another person escaped the home without harm.

The sudden violence at the upscale home near World Golf Village spawned a massive manhunt that included a nationwide alert to be on the lookout for him.

He was arrested following a traffic stop in Norton, Virginia, after another driver reported nearly being run off the road. He was later extradited to Florida.

Prosecutors plan to seek the death penalty if Colley is convicted.

Copyright 2018 by WJXT News4Jax - All rights reserved.