Is it Duval or St. Johns?: This unique neighborhood on the border has a foot in both counties

ST. JOHNS/DUVAL COUNTY – The 32259 ZIP code is widely considered to be in St. Johns County.

But there is one Duval County neighborhood off of Race Track Road that has a Jacksonville address.

The map below tells a better story.

The Bartram Creek Preserve neighborhood borders the St. Johns County line almost like a cutout. (Copyright 2025 by WJXT News4JAX - All rights reserved.)

On it, you can see that the Bartram Creek Preserve neighborhood borders the St. Johns County line almost like a cutout.

It causes some confusion for those living there.

News4JAX reporter Tiffany Salameh introduces us to her uncle who’s lived in the neighborhood for the last decade after moving to Florida from New York with his family.

Watch the full story about this unique neighborhood in the video player above.