Donald Smith's motion to block death penalty denied Man accused in girl's June 2013 kidnapping, rape, murder still awaits trial No description found
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A new motion seeking to block the state attorney’s office from seeking the death penalty against an accused child killer has been denied.
Donald Smith is awaiting trial in the 2013 kidnap, rape and murder of 8-year-old Cherish Perrywinkle.
In the new motion filed Tuesday, Smith’s lawyers say the new death penalty law written by the Legislature this year is not retroactive -- the law was rewritten after portions of it were ruled unconstitutional by the U.S. Supreme Court.
Smith’s lawyers argue because of that, he can only be sentenced to life in prison if convicted.
Smith’s much-delayed trial is set for February. He was in court Thursday for a pretrial hearing, where the judge denied the motion to block the death penalty.
Smith is expected in court again Dec. 19.
Copyright 2017 by WJXT News4Jax - All rights reserved.
Watch Katie's hilarious fail at re-gifting gift cards on The Morning Show ▶ 0:58
Watch Katie's hilarious fail at re-gifting gift cards on The Morning Show
Defense team in Jared Bridegan murder case wants ‘crucial’ witness to answer written questions ▶ 0:57
Defense team in Jared Bridegan murder case wants ‘crucial’ witness to answer written questions
Sinkhole on apartment property leaves Westside residents without water since Friday ▶ 1:52
Sinkhole on apartment property leaves Westside residents without water since Friday
Jacksonville street racers will have new option with groundbreaking of Callahan drag strip ▶ 0:59
Jacksonville street racers will have new option with groundbreaking of Callahan drag strip
Jacksonville private school faces setback after $200K in technology stolen ▶ 1:07
Jacksonville private school faces setback after $200K in technology stolen
Jags fans snatching up merchandise as team rides wave of success ▶ 0:54
Jags fans snatching up merchandise as team rides wave of success
News4JAX is tracking Santa on Christmas Eve 🎅 Tune in and show the kids! ▶ 0:45
News4JAX is tracking Santa on Christmas Eve 🎅 Tune in and show the kids!
Workers strike outside San Marco area Starbucks ▶ 0:30
Workers strike outside San Marco area Starbucks
Schools from across Jacksonville join parade to celebrate Raines High's state title ▶ 0:44
Schools from across Jacksonville join parade to celebrate Raines High's state title
Community celebrates Raines High's state title with championship parade ▶ 0:44
Community celebrates Raines High's state title with championship parade
Tiny 'Vette driver steals hearts during Raines championship parade ▶ 0:38
Tiny 'Vette driver steals hearts during Raines championship parade
Jacksonville man who lost home in fire moved to tears after Christmas deliver from News4JAX ▶ 0:20
Jacksonville man who lost home in fire moved to tears after Christmas deliver from News4JAX
Richard's Swing Makeover Pt. 17 ▶ 1:15
Richard's Swing Makeover Pt. 17
Color the Weather: Clayton’s Forecast ☀️📚 ▶ 1:14
Color the Weather: Clayton’s Forecast ☀️📚
Man arrested in connection with 'road rage' shooting ▶ 0:43
Man arrested in connection with 'road rage' shooting
Neighbor describes scene of deadly double shooting in Orange Park ▶ 0:17
Neighbor describes scene of deadly double shooting in Orange Park
Voices of the 904 Ep. 8 - Her spin on placemaking calls people to fall back in love with downtown ▶ 0:30
Voices of the 904 Ep. 8 - Her spin on placemaking calls people to fall back in love with downtown
Prime-time energy for a heavyweight matchup against Denver ▶ 1:13
Prime-time energy for a heavyweight matchup against Denver
Richard's Swing Makeover pt. 16 ▶ 1:41
Richard's Swing Makeover pt. 16
Local advocacy groups deliver 'coal for Christmas' to JEA ▶ 0:47
Local advocacy groups deliver 'coal for Christmas' to JEA
Richard makes Brunswick Stew ▶ 4:20
Richard makes Brunswick Stew
Warming up after the cold snap ▶ 1:26
Warming up after the cold snap
JSO gives update on officer involved shooting in Dinsmore area ▶ 1:04
JSO gives update on officer involved shooting in Dinsmore area
The science behind wind chills ▶ 2:10
The science behind wind chills
Dangerously cold temperatures trigger Freeze Warning, Cold Weather Advisory ▶ 1:24
Dangerously cold temperatures trigger Freeze Warning, Cold Weather Advisory
Previous photo Next photo