Judge gives thousands of Florida voters extra time to fix signatures

Federal judge hearing lawsuits calls Florida 'laughingstock of the world'

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – After a federal judge ordered voters whose mail-in or provisional ballots were rejected because their signatures didn't match those in their voter registration files be given extra time to fix the problem, he slammed Florida for repeatedly failing to anticipate election problems.

U.S. District Judge Mark Walker said the state law on recounts appears to violate the U.S. Supreme Court ruling that decided the presidency in 2000.

"We have been the laughingstock of the world, election after election, and we chose not to fix this," Walker said in court Tuesday.

Walker vented his anger at state lawmakers and at Palm Beach County officials, saying they should have made sure they had enough equipment in place to handle this kind of a recount. Walker also said he's not happy about the idea of extending recount deadlines without limit.

The overarching problem was created by the Florida Legislature, which Walker said passed a recount law that appears to run afoul of the 2000 Bush v. Gore decision, by locking in procedures that don't allow for potential problems.

A total of six election-related lawsuits are pending in Tallahassee. Early Thursday, Walker ordered that voters be given until 5 p.m. Saturday to show a valid identification and fix their ballots if they haven't been counted due to mismatched signatures. Republicans said they would immediately appeal.

State officials testified that nearly 4,000 mailed-in ballots were set aside because local officials decided the signature on the envelope didn't match the signature on file. If these voters can prove their identity, their votes will now be counted and included in final official returns due from each county by noon Sunday.

Duval County election officials said they rejected 268 votes because of signature problems. 

"The folks that have already sent in cures (proof of identification) that were late, we would look at those right now. If those cures are good, we will go ahead and count those ballots," Supervisor of Elections Mike Hogan said. "Those folks have received a letter from us (saying) that they have a problem. They can either come into our office and fill out an affidavit, give us the right date of birth for identification (or) they can fax it or email it to us."

It's not known how at this point, but those "cured" votes will be added to each county's final total, which will probably in with military and civilian mail-in ballots from overseas that are accepted through the close of business Friday.

Florida's 67 counties face a 3 p.m. Thursday deadline to finish recounts that could determine the next senator and governor in one of America's top political battlegrounds, but that original machine recount was the subject of a different legal challenge.

The election supervisor in Palm Beach County, a Democratic stronghold, warned that the county may not meet Thursday's initial deadline, and Leon County Circuit Judge Karen Gievers on Tuesday ruled in favor of a request by the Nelson campaign that Palm Beach should get a five-day extension. But before her office could issue the order in writing, attorneys for Secretary of State Ken Detzner filed a notice to move the case to federal court, meaning Gievers no longer had jurisdiction.

Early Thursday afternoon, Judge Walker rejected Nelson's request, requiring that all 67 counties in Florida must submit their machine recount results by the original deadline. 

In his ruling, Walker said he was concerned that some counties may not complete their work by the deadline, but with a lack of information on when Palm Beach County would wrap up its work, he cannot "fashion a remedy in the dark."

Once the machine recount is complete, state law requires a hand review of races with margins of less than 0.25 percentage points. This almost certainly means another recount in the Senate race, with unofficial results showing Republican Gov. Rick Scott ahead of Nelson by 0.14 percentage points.

Also, the election won't be certified until Tuesday, even though the machine recount may essentially bring a conclusion to the governor's race, where Republican Ron DeSantis leads Democrat Andrew Gillum by 0.41 percentage points in unofficial results.

Nelson, a three-time incumbent, has defended his legal strategy that resulted in Walker's ruling, saying in a statement Wednesday that "it remains the most important goal of my campaign to make sure that every lawful vote be counted correctly in this Senate race, and that Floridians' right to participate in this process is protected."

Republicans, however, say in their own lawsuits and motions that Democrats are trying to change the rules after the voting didn't go their way.

"We will continue to fight to defend Florida law and uphold the will of the voters," said Chris Hartline, a spokesman for Scott.

Nelson and Democrats had wanted Walker to order the counting of all mail-in ballots rejected for a mismatched signature, arguing that local election officials aren't handwriting experts.

Walker said he could not go along with that suggestion.

"Let this court be clear: It is not ordering county canvassing boards to count every mismatched vote, sight unseen," Walker wrote in his 34-page ruling. "Rather, the county supervisors of elections are directed to allow those voters who should have had an opportunity to cure their ballots in the first place to cure their vote-by-mail and provisional ballots now, before the second official results are fully counted. This should give sufficient time, within the state's and counties current administrative constraints, for Florida's voters to ensure their votes will be counted."

Lauren Schenone, a spokeswoman for Scott, called Walker's ruling "baseless" and said the campaign was "confident" it would be overturned by the Atlanta-based appellate court.

The developments are fueling frustrations among Democrats and Republicans alike. Democrats want state officials to do whatever it takes to make sure every eligible vote is counted. Republicans, including President Donald Trump, have argued without evidence that voter fraud threatens to steal races from the GOP.

Just when state officials will get recount results from all counties remains unclear. Tallying machines overheated earlier this week in Palm Beach County. That caused mismatched results with the recount of 174,000 early voting ballots, forcing staffers to go back and redo their work.

The county's supervisor of elections, Susan Bucher, said the machines underwent maintenance right before the election, but "I don't think they were designed to work 24/7."

About the Authors: