US Supreme Court declines to take up Donald Smith’s appeal in murder of Cherish Perrywinkle
Donald Smith
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to take up an appeal in a high-profile case involving an 8-year-old Jacksonville girl who was abducted from a Walmart and raped and murdered.
Death row inmate Donald James Smith took the case to the U.S. Supreme Court last year after the Florida Supreme Court unanimously upheld his conviction and sentence in the 2013 murder of Cherish Perrywinkle .
An attorney for Smith asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the case because of alleged improper arguments by a prosecutor during Smith’s trial.
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the request last week. As is common, justice did not explain their reasons.
RELATED: I-TEAM obtains newly-released evidence against Donald Smith
The murder drew huge amounts of news coverage and public attention in Jacksonville , with a jury in 2018 finding Smith guilty and a judge sending him to death row .
Smith, now 65, is an inmate at Union Correctional Institution, according to the Florida Department of Corrections website.
Cherish Perrywinkle News Service of Florida
One person dead, 2 more sent to hospital after argument turns into fight in St. Johns County ▶ 1:03
One person dead, 2 more sent to hospital after argument turns into fight in St. Johns County
Bus company confirms driver removed from service after unauthorized person boards school bus ▶ 1:35
Bus company confirms driver removed from service after unauthorized person boards school bus
Oceanway residents disappointed in committee’s decision to approve storage unit development ▶ 0:22
Oceanway residents disappointed in committee’s decision to approve storage unit development
UNF poll finds that Florida voters are split on Trump's immigration policy ▶ 0:52
UNF poll finds that Florida voters are split on Trump's immigration policy
Happy clouds on a Happy Humpday. When will we get some rain? ▶ 0:51
Happy clouds on a Happy Humpday. When will we get some rain?
Photos show Jacksonville-based Navy ships, helicopters playing key roles in ‘Operation Epic Fury ▶ 1:08
Photos show Jacksonville-based Navy ships, helicopters playing key roles in ‘Operation Epic Fury
How the Middle East conflict will affect travel ▶ 1:12
How the Middle East conflict will affect travel
St. Johns County deputies pull man away from fiery crash on I-95 ▶ 0:32
St. Johns County deputies pull man away from fiery crash on I-95
Jacksonville HIV advocate warns of crisis as thousands lose medication access ▶ 1:21
Jacksonville HIV advocate warns of crisis as thousands lose medication access
Passion 4 Pets: Taco is looking for his furever home 🌮 ▶ 0:51
Passion 4 Pets: Taco is looking for his furever home 🌮
Race director's Top 5 things to know for a successful Gate River Run -- with a bonus from Melanie ▶ 1:19
Race director's Top 5 things to know for a successful Gate River Run -- with a bonus from Melanie
LIFT JAX, Swisher announce $135M expansion to create jobs for Eastside residents ▶ 0:36
LIFT JAX, Swisher announce $135M expansion to create jobs for Eastside residents
Gas prices spike overnight. Will they continue to rise? ▶ 1:02
Gas prices spike overnight. Will they continue to rise?
Manatees at Jacksonville Zoo & Botanical Gardens enjoy new river habitat ▶ 1:10
Manatees at Jacksonville Zoo & Botanical Gardens enjoy new river habitat
4 cars set on fire at Mandarin apartment complex ▶ 0:22
4 cars set on fire at Mandarin apartment complex
Here Tomorrow is redefining suicide prevention — offering immediate, no-cost support with no wait. ▶ 0:41
Here Tomorrow is redefining suicide prevention — offering immediate, no-cost support with no wait.
Student describes scary moments when unauthorized person boarded school bus & touched her ▶ 1:23
Student describes scary moments when unauthorized person boarded school bus & touched her
Carrico nominates firefighter union leader Randy Wyse for JEA board amid ongoing controversy ▶ 1:10
Carrico nominates firefighter union leader Randy Wyse for JEA board amid ongoing controversy
Impact Christian Back in State Semifinals ▶ 0:38
Impact Christian Back in State Semifinals
Sporting JAX announces St. Johns Town location for stadium, new sports, entertainment district ▶ 1:07
Sporting JAX announces St. Johns Town location for stadium, new sports, entertainment district
JEA leadership saga update ▶ 0:42
JEA leadership saga update
Chain reaction crash on Atlantic Blvd claims the lives of 3 people, injures others ▶ 0:49
Chain reaction crash on Atlantic Blvd claims the lives of 3 people, injures others
News4JAX walks through Jeffrery Epstein's old plane now sitting at a SE GA scrapyard ▶ 1:26
News4JAX walks through Jeffrery Epstein's old plane now sitting at a SE GA scrapyard
Let's get this vertical garden growing! ▶ 4:18
Let's get this vertical garden growing!
What's new in downtown Jacksonville? We take a look at the latest developments ▶ 1:11
What's new in downtown Jacksonville? We take a look at the latest developments
Previous photo Next photo