US Supreme Court declines to take up Donald Smith’s appeal in murder of Cherish Perrywinkle
Donald Smith
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to take up an appeal in a high-profile case involving an 8-year-old Jacksonville girl who was abducted from a Walmart and raped and murdered.
Death row inmate Donald James Smith took the case to the U.S. Supreme Court last year after the Florida Supreme Court unanimously upheld his conviction and sentence in the 2013 murder of Cherish Perrywinkle .
An attorney for Smith asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the case because of alleged improper arguments by a prosecutor during Smith’s trial.
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the request last week. As is common, justice did not explain their reasons.
RELATED: I-TEAM obtains newly-released evidence against Donald Smith
The murder drew huge amounts of news coverage and public attention in Jacksonville , with a jury in 2018 finding Smith guilty and a judge sending him to death row .
Smith, now 65, is an inmate at Union Correctional Institution, according to the Florida Department of Corrections website.
Cherish Perrywinkle News Service of Florida
6-week-old baby dips her toes in water for Polar Plunge at Jacksonville Beach ▶ 0:15
6-week-old baby dips her toes in water for Polar Plunge at Jacksonville Beach
Meteorologist Katie Garner tracks rain through the weekend ▶ 0:55
Meteorologist Katie Garner tracks rain through the weekend
3 separate shootings in Jacksonville during New Year's celebrations in Jacksonville ▶ 0:57
3 separate shootings in Jacksonville during New Year's celebrations in Jacksonville
Fernandina Beach drops the shrimp to celebrate New Year's ▶ 1:54
Fernandina Beach drops the shrimp to celebrate New Year's
Study raises concerns over property values if Florida nixes HOAs ▶ 0:49
Study raises concerns over property values if Florida nixes HOAs
Freeze warning, bitter wind chills as new year approaches ▶ 1:14
Freeze warning, bitter wind chills as new year approaches
Fernandina Beach store owner’s funny response to burglary goes viral ▶ 1:57
Fernandina Beach store owner’s funny response to burglary goes viral
That’s a wrap! Thank you for supporting season 1 of ‘Voices of the 904′ ▶ 0:33
That’s a wrap! Thank you for supporting season 1 of ‘Voices of the 904′
‘They’re not indestructible’: Child e-bike injuries jump by almost 4,000% in three years ▶ 0:51
‘They’re not indestructible’: Child e-bike injuries jump by almost 4,000% in three years
Jonas Brothers show to mark last concert at Daily’s Place before closure for stadium renovations ▶ 0:34
Jonas Brothers show to mark last concert at Daily’s Place before closure for stadium renovations
Man killed in officer-involved shooting ▶ 1:15
Man killed in officer-involved shooting
Cold snap returns to Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia ▶ 1:17
Cold snap returns to Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia
Concerns raised after Jacksonville sees 3 pedestrians killed by vehicles in past week ▶ 0:59
Concerns raised after Jacksonville sees 3 pedestrians killed by vehicles in past week
Mizzou fans get in the spirit at Jacksonville Beach pep rally for TaxSlayer Gator Bowl ▶ 0:31
Mizzou fans get in the spirit at Jacksonville Beach pep rally for TaxSlayer Gator Bowl
Virginia fans get hyped for TaxSlayer Gator Bowl with pep rally in Jacksonville Beach ▶ 0:31
Virginia fans get hyped for TaxSlayer Gator Bowl with pep rally in Jacksonville Beach
Will the Jacksonville Icemen play Friday night despite ECHL strike? ▶ 0:41
Will the Jacksonville Icemen play Friday night despite ECHL strike?
Community steps up to help after food truck owner's trailer stolen on Christmas morning ▶ 0:27
Community steps up to help after food truck owner's trailer stolen on Christmas morning
Man dies in Christmas Eve shooting outside business near St. Augustine Road: JSO ▶ 0:43
Man dies in Christmas Eve shooting outside business near St. Augustine Road: JSO
Jacksonville family moves into home donated by church after losing everything in apartment fire ▶ 1:12
Jacksonville family moves into home donated by church after losing everything in apartment fire
Watch Katie's hilarious fail at re-gifting gift cards on The Morning Show ▶ 0:58
Watch Katie's hilarious fail at re-gifting gift cards on The Morning Show
Defense team in Jared Bridegan murder case wants ‘crucial’ witness to answer written questions ▶ 0:57
Defense team in Jared Bridegan murder case wants ‘crucial’ witness to answer written questions
Sinkhole on apartment property leaves Westside residents without water since Friday ▶ 1:52
Sinkhole on apartment property leaves Westside residents without water since Friday
Jacksonville street racers will have new option with groundbreaking of Callahan drag strip ▶ 0:59
Jacksonville street racers will have new option with groundbreaking of Callahan drag strip
Jacksonville private school faces setback after $200K in technology stolen ▶ 1:07
Jacksonville private school faces setback after $200K in technology stolen
Jags fans snatching up merchandise as team rides wave of success ▶ 0:54
Jags fans snatching up merchandise as team rides wave of success
Previous photo Next photo 