US Supreme Court declines to take up Donald Smith’s appeal in murder of Cherish Perrywinkle
Donald Smith
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to take up an appeal in a high-profile case involving an 8-year-old Jacksonville girl who was abducted from a Walmart and raped and murdered.
Death row inmate Donald James Smith took the case to the U.S. Supreme Court last year after the Florida Supreme Court unanimously upheld his conviction and sentence in the 2013 murder of Cherish Perrywinkle .
An attorney for Smith asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the case because of alleged improper arguments by a prosecutor during Smith’s trial.
The U.S. Supreme Court rejected the request last week. As is common, justice did not explain their reasons.
RELATED: I-TEAM obtains newly-released evidence against Donald Smith
The murder drew huge amounts of news coverage and public attention in Jacksonville , with a jury in 2018 finding Smith guilty and a judge sending him to death row .
Smith, now 65, is an inmate at Union Correctional Institution, according to the Florida Department of Corrections website.
Cherish Perrywinkle News Service of Florida
St. Marys Elementary to remain closed Tuesday as crews remove bats found in building ▶ 0:58
St. Marys Elementary to remain closed Tuesday as crews remove bats found in building
Split Happens Ep. 6: Why courtroom etiquette matters more than you think ▶ 1:23
Split Happens Ep. 6: Why courtroom etiquette matters more than you think
Jacksonville Free Press reporter's comments to Jags coach Liam Coen after playoff loss spark debate ▶ 2:03
Jacksonville Free Press reporter's comments to Jags coach Liam Coen after playoff loss spark debate
Cold front to bring chilly temperatures to Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia ▶ 1:13
Cold front to bring chilly temperatures to Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia
DeSantis announces ‘historic’ rate reductions for Citizens Insurance policyholders ▶ 0:51
DeSantis announces ‘historic’ rate reductions for Citizens Insurance policyholders
Sheriff Waters on recent officer-involved shootings ▶ 0:50
Sheriff Waters on recent officer-involved shootings
Family divided: News4JAX reporter Sophia Vitello good-naturedly grapples with her mom's Bills fandom ▶ 0:59
Family divided: News4JAX reporter Sophia Vitello good-naturedly grapples with her mom's Bills fandom
Buffalo Bills fans make their presence known ahead of Sunday's playoff showdown ▶ 0:37
Buffalo Bills fans make their presence known ahead of Sunday's playoff showdown
Capt. Duval came over from London and shares his love for the Jags and the people of Duval County ▶ 0:55
Capt. Duval came over from London and shares his love for the Jags and the people of Duval County
Mayor Donna Deegan welcomes Buffalo fans but predicts they'll be going home sad ▶ 0:58
Mayor Donna Deegan welcomes Buffalo fans but predicts they'll be going home sad
Jaguars Jeopardy: Do you know as much about the Jags as our contestants? ▶ 1:12
Jaguars Jeopardy: Do you know as much about the Jags as our contestants?
Airport therapy dogs win over Bills fans in Jacksonville | 'Best welcome we've ever had' ▶ 0:43
Airport therapy dogs win over Bills fans in Jacksonville | 'Best welcome we've ever had'
Last call for Nights of Lights! ▶ 0:29
Last call for Nights of Lights!
Jags superfan from London explains his fandom ▶ 0:49
Jags superfan from London explains his fandom
Jaguars fans across 'Duuuval' are ready to take on the Buffalo Bills ▶ 0:51
Jaguars fans across 'Duuuval' are ready to take on the Buffalo Bills
Liam Coen's father, Tim, has been his inspiration throughout career ▶ 1:39
Liam Coen's father, Tim, has been his inspiration throughout career
Man dies, another rescued after boating accident on Crescent Lake, FWC says ▶ 1:11
Man dies, another rescued after boating accident on Crescent Lake, FWC says
Jaguars fans are hyped for Sunday's playoff game ▶ 0:53
Jaguars fans are hyped for Sunday's playoff game
News4JAX tailgate ahead of the Jaguars playoff game ▶ 1:47
News4JAX tailgate ahead of the Jaguars playoff game
Inflammatory comments made by Clay County School Board member addressed at Thursday meeting ▶ 1:31
Inflammatory comments made by Clay County School Board member addressed at Thursday meeting
Jacksonville protesters call for justice after ICE agent shoots, kills woman in Minnesota ▶ 0:43
Jacksonville protesters call for justice after ICE agent shoots, kills woman in Minnesota
Protesters gather outside Clay County School Board meeting to call for Robert Alvero's resignation ▶ 1:19
Protesters gather outside Clay County School Board meeting to call for Robert Alvero's resignation
Moment of silence held outside Duval County Courthouse for woman killed by ICE in Minneapolis ▶ 0:08
Moment of silence held outside Duval County Courthouse for woman killed by ICE in Minneapolis
Community rallies behind Jacksonville father after wife’s tragic death following birth of 6th child ▶ 0:44
Community rallies behind Jacksonville father after wife’s tragic death following birth of 6th child
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills ▶ 1:27
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills
Previous photo Next photo