Teen Gets Life In Pizza Driver's Murder 2 Other Teens Who Pleaded Guilty To Be Sentenced Next Week
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A 16-year-old convicted of murdering a pizza delivery driver in December was sentenced to life in prison Thursday.
Jonathan Hartley was one of three teens who pleaded guilty to killing 57-year-old Sarah Hotham. Hotham was delivering pizza at an apartment complex on Comanche Street when she was shot.
The state attorney's office had recommended a 50-year sentence for Hartley, but Judge Charles Arnold said he wanted to make an example regarding all the teenage crime in Jacksonville and handed down a life sentence.
Hartley claimed the shooting was an accident after Hotham refused to give him any money. He broke down crying when the sentence was announced.
Gregory Byrd Jr., 18, and Keon Sams, 17, the two other teens who pleaded guilty in the murder, will be sentenced next week.
Copyright 2011 by News4Jax.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Jaguars reveal truth about Trevor Lawrence’s new hairdo ▶ 1:07
Jaguars reveal truth about Trevor Lawrence’s new hairdo
A look at the Jaguars 2026 schedule! ▶ 1:10
A look at the Jaguars 2026 schedule!
Jacksonville IRONMAN Triathlon begins Saturday; US Coast Guard says there will be increased security ▶ 1:00
Jacksonville IRONMAN Triathlon begins Saturday; US Coast Guard says there will be increased security
Man shot by JSO after hostage situation involving woman, infant ▶ 2:20
Man shot by JSO after hostage situation involving woman, infant
Brysen Wright with the endzone look in spring… saving the real magic for the season ▶ 0:13
Brysen Wright with the endzone look in spring… saving the real magic for the season
Safety Dance activated 😂 Mandarin Mustangs out here celebrating that 2-piece special. #Varsity4 ▶ 0:18
Safety Dance activated 😂 Mandarin Mustangs out here celebrating that 2-piece special. #Varsity4
When Hicks Zarah gets downhill… it’s over for whoever’s in the way 🛑 #Varsity4 ▶ 0:15
When Hicks Zarah gets downhill… it’s over for whoever’s in the way 🛑 #Varsity4
Attorney for off-duty JSO officer accused in skate park takedown pleased after client cleared ▶ 0:34
Attorney for off-duty JSO officer accused in skate park takedown pleased after client cleared
Battle over beer brewing: Hastings church appeals pizza restaurant’s alcohol approval ▶ 1:05
Battle over beer brewing: Hastings church appeals pizza restaurant’s alcohol approval
Man found fatally shot near Normandy Boulevard on Jacksonville’s Westside ▶ 1:11
Man found fatally shot near Normandy Boulevard on Jacksonville’s Westside
When Kyree Wilson gets the ball in space… it’s a wrap 😤 ▶ 0:20
When Kyree Wilson gets the ball in space… it’s a wrap 😤
Pt. 2: Batteries out. Parts off. New tools and toys for This Old Golf Cart ▶ 4:02
Pt. 2: Batteries out. Parts off. New tools and toys for This Old Golf Cart
'Erased is a good one': Jaguars rookie WR Josh Cameron dishes on his favorite hobby: anime ▶ 0:36
'Erased is a good one': Jaguars rookie WR Josh Cameron dishes on his favorite hobby: anime
At 73 and still going strong, Susan Wallis continues to inspire as she gets ready for 48th Ironman ▶ 1:48
At 73 and still going strong, Susan Wallis continues to inspire as she gets ready for 48th Ironman
Eva Longear-ia needs a home! 🐶🏡 ▶ 1:08
Eva Longear-ia needs a home! 🐶🏡
News4JAX ride-along with JSO DUI Patrol on Cinco de Mayo ends with arrest ▶ 2:31
News4JAX ride-along with JSO DUI Patrol on Cinco de Mayo ends with arrest
Phase III water limits hit homeowners across Northeast Florida ▶ 0:45
Phase III water limits hit homeowners across Northeast Florida
Jacksonville unveils Riverfront Music Garden, reopen Northbank Riverwalk to honor city’s heritage ▶ 1:45
Jacksonville unveils Riverfront Music Garden, reopen Northbank Riverwalk to honor city’s heritage
City of Jacksonville shares details, gathers input on next phase of Riverfront Plaza ▶ 1:34
City of Jacksonville shares details, gathers input on next phase of Riverfront Plaza
Joshua Phillips withdraws bid for sentence review, cites need for professional counseling ▶ 1:43
Joshua Phillips withdraws bid for sentence review, cites need for professional counseling
Hold up wait a minute, I'm about to put some green in it! ▶ 4:59
Hold up wait a minute, I'm about to put some green in it!
Shanna Gardner, Henry Tenon return to court for another pre-trial hearing ▶ 0:42
Shanna Gardner, Henry Tenon return to court for another pre-trial hearing
Fatal road rage shooting of Jacksonville musician Joe Starkey was justified under Florida law: SAO ▶ 1:22
Fatal road rage shooting of Jacksonville musician Joe Starkey was justified under Florida law: SAO
Affordable housing project planned for Springfield as development reshapes neighborhood ▶ 1:11
Affordable housing project planned for Springfield as development reshapes neighborhood
Jacksonville councilwoman declines to comment on HR investigation that removed her from classroom ▶ 0:35
Jacksonville councilwoman declines to comment on HR investigation that removed her from classroom
Previous photo Next photo
