Resentencing begins Monday for woman convicted of helping kidnap, bury elderly Jacksonville couple alive Reggie and Carol Sumner were found in a shallow grave
Tiffany Cole resentencing starts Monday under new death penalty law (News4JAX)
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – The woman convicted of helping kidnap an elderly Jacksonville couple and bury them alive will be back in court Monday for a re-sentencing hearing.
Tiffany Cole was sentenced to death in connection with the 2005 crime, but since the jury’s recommendations were not unanimous, she has been granted a new sentencing hearing.
Related: Resentencing trial continues for one of the men convicted of burying local couple alive
Cole and three others kidnapped and robbed Reggie and Carol Sumner — who both had health issues — then drove them to a remote part of Charlton County, Georgia and buried the couple alive.
Cole is one of only three women on Florida’s death row.
It should be noted that current Florida law requires only an 8 to 4 jury recommendation for Cole to be re-sentenced to death.
Copyright 2023 by WJXT News4JAX - All rights reserved.
DCPS is set to lose $3.2 million in state funds that helps students save on college ▶ 1:45
DCPS is set to lose $3.2 million in state funds that helps students save on college
Jacksonville Beach wedding becomes viral moment during ‘Senior Skip Day’ ▶ 0:59
Jacksonville Beach wedding becomes viral moment during ‘Senior Skip Day’
Family of child injured in school bus crash on Zoo Parkway plans to pursue legal action ▶ 1:50
Family of child injured in school bus crash on Zoo Parkway plans to pursue legal action
St. Johns County’s LAMP program sets sights on 5 properties after missing last year’s top priority ▶ 1:07
St. Johns County’s LAMP program sets sights on 5 properties after missing last year’s top priority
Simple safety habits to help Jacksonville drivers stay in their lane, avoid trouble spots ▶ 1:21
Simple safety habits to help Jacksonville drivers stay in their lane, avoid trouble spots
Local businesses anticipate impacts from Pearl Street Square development ▶ 1:20
Local businesses anticipate impacts from Pearl Street Square development
DCPS open doors to showcase career, technology programs after TikTok petition ▶ 1:01
DCPS open doors to showcase career, technology programs after TikTok petition
Ready for some fun at the Clay County Fair? ▶ 1:16
Ready for some fun at the Clay County Fair?
Parents shocked after semi slams rear end of school bus carrying kindergartners ▶ 0:40
Parents shocked after semi slams rear end of school bus carrying kindergartners
Florida’s SAVE Act to change voter registration rule ▶ 1:40
Florida’s SAVE Act to change voter registration rule
The Clay County Fair is officially open! Here's what to know ▶ 1:09
The Clay County Fair is officially open! Here's what to know
4 kindergarten students hurt, semi smashes back of school bus crossing train tracks on Zoo Parkway ▶ 1:06
4 kindergarten students hurt, semi smashes back of school bus crossing train tracks on Zoo Parkway
St. Johns Country Day girls soccer head coach Mike Pickett has stepped down ▶ 1:10
St. Johns Country Day girls soccer head coach Mike Pickett has stepped down
Teal Tower: Thousands of old EverBank Stadium seats ready to be recycled ▶ 1:00
Teal Tower: Thousands of old EverBank Stadium seats ready to be recycled
New traffic safety garden keeps legacy alive of Ed White student athlete killed in hit-and-run ▶ 1:16
New traffic safety garden keeps legacy alive of Ed White student athlete killed in hit-and-run
Visitors relive Moon-mission memories as Artemis II lights up the sky | 'Sends chills through me' ▶ 1:08
Visitors relive Moon-mission memories as Artemis II lights up the sky | 'Sends chills through me'
More details released on Jax Beach ‘Senior Skip Day’ arrests, gun seizures ▶ 1:25
More details released on Jax Beach ‘Senior Skip Day’ arrests, gun seizures
A St. Johns County mother’s push for ‘Trenton’s Law’ gains attention after Tiger Woods DUI arrest ▶ 0:51
A St. Johns County mother’s push for ‘Trenton’s Law’ gains attention after Tiger Woods DUI arrest
Tony Boselli sees Orlando home for Jaguars in 2027 as a major positive ▶ 0:59
Tony Boselli sees Orlando home for Jaguars in 2027 as a major positive
Jaguars, Orlando officials unveil team's 2027 temporary home ▶ 1:17
Jaguars, Orlando officials unveil team's 2027 temporary home
Parents say DCPS adding stop-arm cameras to buses gives them peace of mind ▶ 0:57
Parents say DCPS adding stop-arm cameras to buses gives them peace of mind
ramps at First Coast Expressway, SR 16 interchange officially open ahead of Clay County Fair ▶ 0:43
ramps at First Coast Expressway, SR 16 interchange officially open ahead of Clay County Fair
One woman’s love for books is still turning pages and changing lives ▶ 0:38
One woman’s love for books is still turning pages and changing lives
Forecast: 100% chance of cute as kindergartners bring letters to News4JAX meteorologist Katie Garner ▶ 1:02
Forecast: 100% chance of cute as kindergartners bring letters to News4JAX meteorologist Katie Garner
$5K UF scholarships available to incoming freshmen with military ties ▶ 1:10
$5K UF scholarships available to incoming freshmen with military ties
Previous photo Next photo
