Report: 'Insufficient evidence' to charge teen after shots fired into car Disposition statement reveals why charges were dropped against Caleb Sheffield No description found
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A disposition statement obtained Wednesday by News4Jax sheds light on why charges were dropped in the case of a 17-year-old who was arrested in June after shots were fired at a car carrying four people.
News4Jax learned Caleb Sheffield was released from jail when video surfaced showing him in Orlando near the time of the shooting.
According to the report, the video -- as well as statements from witnesses who would testify Sheffield was in Orlando about an hour and 30 minutes before the time of the shooting in Jacksonville -- was one of three reasons why the charges were dropped.
After a victim of the shooting was released from the hospital, she spoke with investigators, saying she was not sure it was Sheffield who shot her, the report said. It said she told investigators she only got a glance at the shooter and that it was dark outside.
Detectives submitted a live round found at the scene for testing, according to the report. The report stated that Sheffield's DNA was not found on the bullet.
Police arrested Sheffield after two women who were in the car were hit by gunfire . His arrest was based on eyewitness testimony.
Copyright 2019 by WJXT News4Jax - All rights reserved.
St. Johns County recorded zero criminal homicides in 2025 ▶ 0:29
St. Johns County recorded zero criminal homicides in 2025
Florida leads nation in foreclosure filings, but experts say it’s not a repeat of 2008 housing crash ▶ 1:27
Florida leads nation in foreclosure filings, but experts say it’s not a repeat of 2008 housing crash
Jacksonville mom says missed school bus pickups put her sons' education, her job at risk ▶ 1:23
Jacksonville mom says missed school bus pickups put her sons' education, her job at risk
Dee Brown JU Highlights ▶ 0:58
Dee Brown JU Highlights
Another chilly start across Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia ▶ 0:25
Another chilly start across Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia
Indiana, Miami fans bring college spirit to Jacksonville for national championship battle ▶ 0:34
Indiana, Miami fans bring college spirit to Jacksonville for national championship battle
Florida bills aim to regulate mobile home rent hikes ▶ 1:31
Florida bills aim to regulate mobile home rent hikes
2 shootings, armed robbery reported across 3 Jacksonville fast-food restaurants over the weekend ▶ 1:10
2 shootings, armed robbery reported across 3 Jacksonville fast-food restaurants over the weekend
Deputy recovering after shootout with man accused of killing his father in Baker County ▶ 0:51
Deputy recovering after shootout with man accused of killing his father in Baker County
City blight initiatives manager pushing for increased funding to address illegal dumping ▶ 1:01
City blight initiatives manager pushing for increased funding to address illegal dumping
Chief Meteorologist Richard Nunn says our frigid, frosty forecast isn't over yet ▶ 0:38
Chief Meteorologist Richard Nunn says our frigid, frosty forecast isn't over yet
Honoring legacy of civil rights icon at Jacksonville’s 45th annual MLK Holiday Parade ▶ 0:55
Honoring legacy of civil rights icon at Jacksonville’s 45th annual MLK Holiday Parade
5 side hustles that actually work! ▶ 0:15
5 side hustles that actually work!
Tracking rain before freezing temperatures arrive ▶ 0:51
Tracking rain before freezing temperatures arrive
Snow flurry potential in Southeast Georgia on Sunday ▶ 0:56
Snow flurry potential in Southeast Georgia on Sunday
Safety concerns at A1A and TPC Blvd ▶ 1:03
Safety concerns at A1A and TPC Blvd
Questions remain as JSO continues Springfield double death investigation ▶ 1:24
Questions remain as JSO continues Springfield double death investigation
Jacksonville protesters bash ICE operations, demand city employee be reinstated ▶ 0:45
Jacksonville protesters bash ICE operations, demand city employee be reinstated
In case you haven't noticed, it's been a little cold in Jacksonville... ▶ 1:23
In case you haven't noticed, it's been a little cold in Jacksonville...
Fernandina Beach community rallies behind woman fighting to keep food pantry open ▶ 1:11
Fernandina Beach community rallies behind woman fighting to keep food pantry open
Reporter Ariel Schiller has all the info you need for warming centers in Jacksonville ▶ 1:12
Reporter Ariel Schiller has all the info you need for warming centers in Jacksonville
THROWBACK THURSDAY: David Robinson practices with JU ▶ 0:52
THROWBACK THURSDAY: David Robinson practices with JU
Woman facing multiple charges after punching trooper in the face during ICE encounter, AG says ▶ 0:45
Woman facing multiple charges after punching trooper in the face during ICE encounter, AG says
Florida AG says Nassau County can’t justify big impact fee rate hike despite 17% population increase ▶ 1:18
Florida AG says Nassau County can’t justify big impact fee rate hike despite 17% population increase
Chilly Thursday gives way to freezing weather in Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia ▶ 1:27
Chilly Thursday gives way to freezing weather in Northeast Florida, Southeast Georgia
Previous photo Next photo