LAKE CITY, Fla. – A friend of Caitlyn Frisina said the 17-year-old was in a relationship with her high school's 27-year-old soccer coach who she took off with a week ago, but she did not want to leave the country with him didn't know what to do, according to court documents.
Caitlyn and Rian Rodriguez, 27, were the center of a nationwide search that ended after 4 p.m. Friday when they were pulled over by a New York State Police officer who spotted the red Mercury Sable the pair had driven from Columbia County, Florida.
New York State Police Sgt. Murray Smith said police were actively checking hotel and business parking lots before they spotted
Caitlyn was reunited with her parents Saturday in Syracuse. The family is expected to return to Florida sometime Sunday.
According to Rodriguez’s arrest report, Caitlyn’s mother, Scarlet Frisina, had been calling her daughter's friends and discovered Caitlyn’s relationship with Rodriguez. One of Caitlyn’s friends told Frisina that her daughter had “hooked up” with Rodriguez and he worked his way into her life.
Frisina said Friday before her daughter was found that Rodriguez was the only person who didn't answer when she and her husband were calling around trying to find Caitlyn Sunday morning.
The records detail a conversation Caitlyn had with the friend. According to the friend, Caitlyn said the two were planning to leave and she (Caitlyn) didn’t know how to get out of going. Caitlyn told her friend that if she did get out of going, Rodriguez said he would “mess up her life,” according to Rodriguez’s arrest report.
Caitlyn told her friend that she was "scared and didn’t know what to do," police said.
Arrest records show that a school resource officer in Lake City handled a rumor that Caitlyn and Rodriguez were in a relationship in August, just after the school year started. The officer concluded that the rumor was a false accusation.
News4Ja crime and safety analyst Gil Smith spent six years working as a school resource officer said the student who made the claim, but later said her story wasn't true may have felt pressure to change their mind.
"Once they know they're going to be interviewed and talked to by several different people, they may have gotten the cold shoulder," Smith said.
Caitlyn’s father, Ward Frisina, told police that after checking his daughter’s bank account, he saw that she withdrew $200 from an ATM in St. Marys, Georgia.
Ward Frisina found her cellphone in her bedroom and a factory reset had been performed on it. According to documents, he told police he was able to pull some old Snapchat messages that confirmed her relationship with Rodriquez.
In the messages, Caitlyn makes explicit remarks about Rodriguez’s genitals.
Ward Frisina told police he made several attempts to contact Rodriguez, including leaving messages on his voicemail.
Rodriguez’s arrest report shows that he told his parents that he was leaving to visit a friend that lives near a Catholic church in Lake City, but never returned.
According to his arrest records, Rodriguez took a Discover credit card that belonged to his father and was used in Hardeeville and St. George, South Carolina.
The Columbia County Sheriff’s Office asked Rodriguez’s cellphone service provider to ping Rodriguez's phone, but that wasn't successful because Rodriguez kept his cellphone off, police said.
New York State Police Trooper Jack Keller told reporters that Rodriguez might have come to the area because had spent a couple of summer vacations here when he was younger and had some connections here.
Rodriguez was arrested on a charge of interference in child custody, deputies said. He will face an extradition hearing in Onondaga County, New York, on Monday.
"There could be additional charges if they find out she was threatened by Mr. Rodriguez," Smith said.