Founder of Florida-based immigration law firm breaks down what the 14th Amendment says about birthright citizenship
JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A federal judge on Thursday temporarily blocked President Donald Trump’s executive order denying US citizenship to the children of parents living in the country illegally. The judge called it “blatantly unconstitutional.” It is the first hearing in a multi-state effort challenging the order.
President Trump issued the executive order on his first day in office. His directive applies not only to the children of undocumented people but also to the children of a vast group of immigrants who are lawfully in the country.
That includes visa holders who’ve lived here for years.
Renata Castro, founder of “USA4All ,” a Florida-based immigration law firm joined News4JAX anchor Bruce Hamilton. They discussed the issue, which she said is rooted in the plain text and original meaning of the 14th Amendment, enshrined in well over a century of precedent and practice.
Press the play button above to watch the interview.
Copyright 2025 by WJXT News4JAX - All rights reserved.
About the Author Bruce Hamilton headshot
This Emmy Award-winning television, radio and newspaper journalist has anchored The Morning Show for 18 years.
Jaguars fans across 'Duuuval' are ready to take on the Buffalo Bills ▶ 0:51
Jaguars fans across 'Duuuval' are ready to take on the Buffalo Bills
Liam Coen's father, Tim, has been his inspiration throughout career ▶ 1:39
Liam Coen's father, Tim, has been his inspiration throughout career
Man dies, another rescued after boating accident on Crescent Lake, FWC says ▶ 1:11
Man dies, another rescued after boating accident on Crescent Lake, FWC says
Jaguars fans are hyped for Sunday's playoff game ▶ 0:53
Jaguars fans are hyped for Sunday's playoff game
News4JAX tailgate ahead of the Jaguars playoff game ▶ 1:47
News4JAX tailgate ahead of the Jaguars playoff game
Inflammatory comments made by Clay County School Board member addressed at Thursday meeting ▶ 1:31
Inflammatory comments made by Clay County School Board member addressed at Thursday meeting
Jacksonville protesters call for justice after ICE agent shoots, kills woman in Minnesota ▶ 0:43
Jacksonville protesters call for justice after ICE agent shoots, kills woman in Minnesota
Protesters gather outside Clay County School Board meeting to call for Robert Alvero's resignation ▶ 1:19
Protesters gather outside Clay County School Board meeting to call for Robert Alvero's resignation
Moment of silence held outside Duval County Courthouse for woman killed by ICE in Minneapolis ▶ 0:08
Moment of silence held outside Duval County Courthouse for woman killed by ICE in Minneapolis
Community rallies behind Jacksonville father after wife’s tragic death following birth of 6th child ▶ 0:44
Community rallies behind Jacksonville father after wife’s tragic death following birth of 6th child
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills ▶ 1:27
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills
Foggy start to Thursday ▶ 0:35
Foggy start to Thursday
JTA approves program to lower fares for bus systems, remove all costs to ride NAVI shuttles downtown ▶ 0:31
JTA approves program to lower fares for bus systems, remove all costs to ride NAVI shuttles downtown
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills ▶ 1:27
Breakdown of Jaguars Wild Card matchup against the Buffalo Bills
Superstitious Jaguars fan refuses to take down old Halloween decoration because they keep winning ▶ 0:50
Superstitious Jaguars fan refuses to take down old Halloween decoration because they keep winning
Nassau County woman trying to help after learning school lunch debt is up to $200K ▶ 0:51
Nassau County woman trying to help after learning school lunch debt is up to $200K
Service and therapy dogs to greet Bills fans at JAX ahead of game ▶ 0:35
Service and therapy dogs to greet Bills fans at JAX ahead of game
Duval County School Board adds Schools of Hope to legislative agenda amid parent concerns ▶ 0:50
Duval County School Board adds Schools of Hope to legislative agenda amid parent concerns
‘He’ll be missed’: Family of bicyclist killed in hit-and-run pleads for witnesses to come forward ▶ 0:51
‘He’ll be missed’: Family of bicyclist killed in hit-and-run pleads for witnesses to come forward
Raines Vikings celebrated at DCPS school board meeting ▶ 0:58
Raines Vikings celebrated at DCPS school board meeting
Westside apartment complex again under scrutiny as residents report squatters, safety concerns ▶ 0:36
Westside apartment complex again under scrutiny as residents report squatters, safety concerns
2 separate police-involved shootings leave one man dead, one injured ▶ 0:57
2 separate police-involved shootings leave one man dead, one injured
Start your new year off right with these events from Jan. 9 - 11 ▶ 1:04
Start your new year off right with these events from Jan. 9 - 11
Start 2026 with purpose: Volunteer for United Way Northeast Florida’s MLK Day of Service ▶ 0:30
Start 2026 with purpose: Volunteer for United Way Northeast Florida’s MLK Day of Service
Man killed in officer-involved shooting in Bartram Park area ▶ 1:24
Man killed in officer-involved shooting in Bartram Park area
Previous photo Next photo