Grading the Jaguars pick of LSU receiver Brian Thomas Jr.: Solid across the board

LSU wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr., center, catches a touchdown pass over Mississippi cornerback Zamari Walton, left, during the second half of an NCAA college football game in Oxford, Miss., Saturday, Sept. 30, 2023. (AP Photo/Thomas Graning) (Thomas Graning, Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.)

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – The Jaguars traded back in the first round of the NFL draft, moving from No. 17 to 23. They pocketed three additional picks in the process, and used their first-rounder to select LSU receiver Brian Thomas Jr. The News4JAX sports staff grades the selection and the move of general manager Trent Baalke.

RELATED

Recommended Videos



WATCH: The News4JAGs one-hour draft special

Jaguars unveil 30th anniversary logo before draft

The News4JAX sports staff makes its picks for the Jaguars

Fans share their NFL draft party photos

Antonio Johnson looks back at his NFL draft experience

Team president Mark Lamping talks about draft, 30th year

The five worst draft classes in Jaguars history

The five best draft classes in Jaguars history

Jamal St. Cyr: A++

With the trade back I love the move. Trade back Trent. Somebody que up “Many Men” by 50 Cent. This was a masterclass kind of move by Baalke. Brian Thomas Jr. is a crazy athlete and gives Trevor Lawrence a new big, fast wide receiver to throw to. If they took him at 17 my grade would be different. But with the picks they added in the trade back I have to give the pick the highest possible grade.

Alessandra Pontbriand: A

Well, I was wrong. The Jaguars traded down, which I thought was the last thing the team would do. They also took a wide receiver. I thought they would pick a cornerback. Fans should be excited for LSU’s Brian Thomas Jr. Like his draft position, he’s definitely the fourth-best receiver in this year’s draft. His combination of size (6-3, 209 pounds), speed (4.33 in the 40-yard dash) and proven production is an exciting addition to the Jaguars receivers room. Not only did the Jaguars get a receiver they wanted, they also got another draft pick this year and two more next year.

Justin Barney: A-

I love the trade back and getting three additional draft picks, especially the third-rounder next year. That’s huge. I wouldn’t have graded this as high if Thomas had gone at 17 though. There are a couple concerns I have, although I generally like the pick and have liked the thought of Thomas in Jacksonville. The history for the Jaguars in drafting receivers in the first round is dubious. They are 0 for 4 in that department (Reggie Williams, Matt Jones, Justin Blackmon and R. Jay Soward). So, that history does make me a skeptical by association. He was the second option in Baton Rouge behind Malik Nabers, so how will Thomas fare with more attention his way? What I love about the pick is his speed and size. Jacksonville needed a big bodied receiver in the worst possible way. He’s not going to need to come in and be WR1 right off the bat and that’s why I think Thomas will have more success with the Jaguars than any of its previous four first-round whiffs.


About the Authors

Justin Barney joined News4Jax in February 2019, but he’s been covering sports on the First Coast for more than 20 years.

Jamal St. Cyr is an award-winning sports anchor who joined the News4Jax sports team in 2019.

Recommended Videos