wjxt logo

Woman found with daughter's body indicted for 1st-degree murder

Jacksonville woman arrested in 2017 after crash in West Virginia

Tygart Valley Regional Jail booking photo of Erica Newsome shown on photo of police searching Newsome's Jacksonville home.
Tygart Valley Regional Jail booking photo of Erica Newsome shown on photo of police searching Newsome's Jacksonville home.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A grand jury indicted a Jacksonville woman for first-degree murder after police found her with her 11-year-old daughter's body following a crash in West Virginia, according to the State Attorney's Office.

In addition, Erica Newsome, 37, is charged with aggravated child abuse and child neglect. She faces a sentence of mandatory life in prison, unless the State of Florida provides notice of its intent to seek the death penalty.

Originally, Newsome was charged with second-degree murder.

Police responding to that crash said Newsome was standing next to her daughter's body near an embankment where her truck crashed.

Newsome's arrest warrant details the injuries found on Kaye-lea Plummer's body. Also, it reveals cellphone searches Newsome made before investigators said she left her home in the Oceanway neighborhood of Jacksonville on Aug. 4, 2017 to head to Buffalo, New York, where Kaye-lea's father lives.

Among the cellphone searches, the warrant says, were phrases including "Alligator Ponds," "Fatal Bridge Accidents in Jacksonville," "Fatal Car Accidents off Cliffs in Flames," "People Killed on Virginia Cliffs" and "Virginia Highways that Has Huge Cliff."

According to the arrest warrant, witnesses reported Newsome removing the girl's body from her truck after striking a guard rail on Allegheny Mountain, a mile and a half west of the Virginia border, on Aug. 6.

The trooper who responded to the crash said he discovered Newsome standing next to the body, which was wrapped in a comforter, at the bottom of a large embankment -- about 150 yards from the scene of the crash.

The trooper reported that EMTs called to the scene said, "The child had been dead for 'a while,'" according to the warrant.

The medical examiner in West Virginia determined the manner of death to be homicide, saying there were multiple injuries on the 11-year-old's body, which were "evidence of aggravated child abuse,"" according to the warrant. 

The injuries to the victim's head, torso and extremities "were determined to be due to assault and contributed to her death," the warrant says.

The medical examiner also noted evidence of "strangulation and/or suffocation," and the child's body mass index showed signs of malnutrition, the warrant states.


About the Author:

Lifetime Jacksonville resident, journalist and experienced broadcast news producer with a passion for classic and exotic cars.