JACKSONVILLE, Fla. – A man accused of shooting and killing his son, former University of Central Florida and University Christian football star Otis Anderson Jr., accepted a plea deal Tuesday and was sentenced to 12.5 years in prison.
Otis Anderson Sr. had previously pleaded not guilty to charges of second-degree murder in the death of his 23-year-old son and second-degree attempted murder for shooting his wife, who survived.
As part of the negotiated deal with prosecutors, Anderson Sr. pleaded guilty Tuesday to two lesser counts of manslaughter and attempted manslaughter.
RELATED: ‘He loved everybody:’ Otis Anderson Jr.’s impact went beyond football field | Father charged with murder of local football star Otis Anderson Jr. pleads not guilty | Attorneys, loved ones request bond for father accused of killing former football star son
He was sentenced to 12 years and six months in state prison on the manslaughter charge and three years on the attempted manslaughter charge. The sentences with run concurrently. Anderson Sr. was credited with 707 days of time served for his sentence.
He will serve five years of probation after he is released and must take part in mental health and anger management treatment.
The deadly shooting happened on Nov. 29, 2021, at the Andersons’ Northside home. According to investigators, it stemmed from an argument after Anderson Sr. was bitten by his son’s girlfriend’s dog.
Anderson Sr. told police he and his son got into a “pushing match” and he grabbed his gun from the garage, his son charged at him, and then he shot him.
According to his arrest report, Anderson Sr. told investigators he shot his son in self-defense and later said if he could reverse his actions for his son to still be alive, he would.
A detective who testified in a previous hearing said Anderson Sr. also shot and wounded his wife after she began hitting him with a Swiffer. Investigators described the wife’s injury as a graze wound.
Anderson Sr.’s wife, Denise, and other family members were in court Tuesday. The judge offered them a chance to speak in court, but they declined.
Denise Anderson’s attorney said there’s no way to describe what she’s lost.
“The emotions haven’t changed today. They’ve been high, you can imagine this entire ordeal. And Mrs. Anderson, she’s happy that this part of the process is over,” Attorney Stephen Kelly said. “I think that Miss Anderson reliving moments and things of that sort would not be in the best interest of her or her family moving forward with this grieving process.”
Kelly also pointed out that while everyone has their own interpretation of how this horrific situation went, they weren’t there and don’t walk in this family’s shoes. Nothing about this was easy for them, Kelly said.